Platoon leader book review. Platoon Leader 2019-01-25

Platoon leader book review Rating: 8,8/10 1277 reviews

Platoon Leader (memoir)

platoon leader book review

It was, and still is, one of the good teaching moments of our time together. For the record I am nonviolent although in my ten years three months in the Canadian Forces I led some neat firefights using blank rounds. They had been hardened by years of war. I received, first hand, the struggles that new leaders may have to overcome with little no actual experience. In the midst of killing, the soldiers became best buddies. Overall well worth a watch!. Norris' direction moves at a fast clip, if quite clichéd cue in the patriotic sounding score but the impulsive action is competently staged and fairly exciting in its tension fuelled fire-fights with glorious slow-motion and graphic violence.

Next

McDonough’s ‘Platoon Leader’: A great memoir by a Vietnam War lieutenant

platoon leader book review

He admits his mistakes, his failures, and his accomplishments all in a very matter-of-fact way. The Author doesn't try to paint a pretty picture, and gives botht the good and the bad, even going to great lengths to point out not only the flaws in the men that he lead, but in himself, and his leadership. It was a man who had experienced it first hand telling of how horrible it was. It also does better than average in depicting real Vietnam combat, and is closer to being realistic than the vast majority of Vietnam movies. There is no attempt in this memoir to hide the ugly side of war, the feelings that cannot help but arise against those who are constantly trying to kill you, and the difficult no win choices that often confront those in command. Jeff Knight, an officer fresh out of West Point who is immediately sent to Vietnam.

Next

Book Review: Outlaw Platoon by Sean Parnell & John Bruning

platoon leader book review

It is {Exhibit 1} at the war crimes trial. But when I ordered it and re-read Platoon Leader I realized how very accurate and explicit the author portraid the responsibilities and dangers that a Platoon leader could expect to experience during his tour of combat duty. But he's a quick learner and not eager to breakdown and spend the war in the dugout the way his predecessor did. One night at my Armories I was acting 14 platoon commander and had my troops work the phones notifying people about the next training night. If the leader loses his own sense of propriety, or shrinks from his duty, anything will be allowed. Dudikoff is likable and charismatic enough action star , but here the role requires someone with far bigger acting talent.

Next

Platoon Leader: A Memoir of Command in Combat by James R. McDonough

platoon leader book review

Highly recommended, even though on occasion I got the impression that the drama may have been heightened a bit. The trapped indigenous people along with the gore and horror of war. I admit, this is some serious guilty pleasure material. The Blu-Ray disc shows no compression artifacts, even in very dark scenes. It is sprinkled generously with gruesome images and experiences and is never humorous.

Next

Platoon Leader: A Memoir of Command in Combat by James R. McDonough

platoon leader book review

A perfect example of this is how he immediately recognized the true and informal leader of his platoon prior to his arrival. It's got lots of great war action, and all the characters were great, plus i really enjoyed the musical score!. A world without rules, mercy and pure ruthless reality. Luckily we had spare clothes and took him into an abandoned barn out of the wind. This kind of intuitiveness is superb for a young leader and a valuable insight that many more can learn from. It is the most personal and graphic book about Vietnam among several that I have read. Dialogue here fares much better, staying properly centered, and sound effects are strong though not nearly as surround-heavy as the first movie.


Next

hometownfamilycare.com

platoon leader book review

The Acting is very good. It's not even funny bad , just bad. The man with the poker face. First of all I'd like to state my opinion that this movie does not deserve the 4. Parnell writes with honesty and clarity; eager to prove himself in battle, he soon gets plenty of opportunities to do so during his tour. His ability to understand the human dimension, the driving force behind each of his Soldiers was crucial in maintaining the integrity of his platoon. The book underscores the sacrificial love soldiers have for each other in combat even though they might not be friends in civilian society or even in their base camp.

Next

Platoon Leader

platoon leader book review

The pool of human resources is vast, and the number of riflemen is small. Parnell's experience as a platoon leader nicknamed Outlaw Platoon for the in Afghanistan. Another reason I would rate it as such and recommend it to other people is because it is written almost like a novel and the characters are so real because they were real people. The action scenes are very well staged and give you a real sense of being there, as opposed to the cardboard pyrotechnics that Cannon usually grinds out. The person who wants to avoid the draft will avoid it. This is an Officer's memoirs of his time in Vietnam.


Next

Platoon Leader (1988)

platoon leader book review

But he wrote it down and he did not mince words: the events, the horror, the justifications, and how the soldiers moved on to the next day to do it again. It has it's B-movie moments but it also has some heart and great human moments. Bad idea, for obvious reasons. This leads to a second raid, where they wind up chasing these two villagers through the jungle and torching the grasslands in slow motion. Naturally, the guys at the base don't take too kindly to Dudikoff when he first arrives, but ultimately grow to respect him, something I've really grown tired of seeing in the movies. Sound's like a good idea for war movie , right?.

Next

Leaders Book Items (hometownfamilycare.com) page 1

platoon leader book review

What I like about this book is his tactical breakdown of situations, patrols and firefights. These raw, controlled scenes of battle seemingly benefit from the authorial collaboration: Besides being a prolific author of military histories, Bruning Chasing Shadows: A Special Agent's Lifelong Hunt to Bring a Cold War Assassin to Justice, 2011, etc. He abandoned the choreography that is standard in almost all war movies. They resented the American presence which threatened them. This methodology has served me well helping Canada Britain and America. The acting is also terrible. It was who said that it's not possible to make an anti-war movie, because all war movies, with their energy and sense of adventure, end up making combat look like fun.


Next

Platoon leader (Book, 1986) [hometownfamilycare.com]

platoon leader book review

This may be the first Viet Nam memoir I've read. Rather than present a potpourri of combat yarns. Rather than present a potpourri of combat yarns. Clinton's robust score hits the rousing spot. The acting, while not spectacular, is still above average compared to the usual Vietnam movies, and the continuity is also slightly above average, and many of the details of uniforms, guns, weapons, speech and the compound is quite accurate.

Next